Abortion Doctor Says GOD Is on Her Side

Planned Parenthood clinic exterior with modern brick facade
Photo: Ken Wolter / Shutterstock

A doctor’s theology and a church’s doctrine rarely occupy the same courtroom, yet in the debate over DeShawn Taylor’s counseling of abortion patients, that is precisely what is happening — two camps citing the same scripture to reach opposite verdicts, with no referee empowered to settle it.

Key Points

  • Dr. DeShawn Taylor, a Phoenix gynecologist and abortion provider, tells patients that abortion is not a sin, and that even if it were, God’s forgiveness covers it.
  • Taylor frames the decision through free will, telling patients that a soul denied one pregnancy will simply arrive through “another vessel”.
  • Critics, including LifeSiteNews and several Christian advocacy organizations, call this reasoning blasphemous and equate abortion with the child sacrifice condemned throughout the Hebrew Bible.
  • The dispute is not primarily about contested facts — both sides largely agree on what Taylor said — but about which theological framework governs those facts, a disagreement scholarship shows runs deep within Christianity itself.
  • No denominational body, biblical scholar, or systematic exegesis has been identified in the record validating Taylor’s specific interpretation, which rests on her own authority as a practicing Christian physician.

What Taylor Actually Says, and to Whom

Taylor runs a Phoenix clinic and is described in reporting as Arizona’s only Black woman-owned abortion practice. Patients who arrive anxious about damnation hear a specific pastoral argument from her: that God operates through free will, and that a soul intended for this world will find another way into it if a particular pregnancy ends. “If God wants that vessel, that spirit to get here, God will choose another vessel. You get to say, ‘I’ll pass,'” she has said. She and some staff reportedly pray with religious patients before procedures and point them toward Bible verses on free will, treating the counseling as integral to clinical care rather than incidental to it.

Taylor extends the argument beyond permission into exoneration. “How did abortion become the one sin that you can’t repent for?” she asks, adding that she does not consider it a sin at all, but that even believers who do should trust that “God is forgiving already”. That is a notably different claim from simple tolerance. She is not merely saying abortion might be excused after the fact; she is arguing that the entire premise of unforgivable sin, as applied to abortion, is a theological error that singles out one act for a severity scripture does not assign it elsewhere.

The Counter-Argument, and Why It Carries Real Weight

The opposing case is not a vague objection — it is a specific, named, and long-standing theological tradition. LifeSiteNews’s Jonathon Van Maren calls Taylor’s position “not merely heresy” but “blasphemy,” arguing that attributing approval of abortion to God inverts scripture’s own language about child sacrifice. The Bible Archaeology Society goes further, arguing that modern abortion parallels the ancient practice of offering children to gods like Molech, and that participating in or approving it “profanes God’s holy name” rather than honoring divine will. The United Church of God and Reformation21 both independently arrive at the same equation — abortion as contemporary child sacrifice, idolatry of individual autonomy over divine authority — using separate scriptural reasoning.

What makes this counter-case substantive rather than merely reactive is its convergence: four separate Christian sources, writing independently, land on structurally the same argument — that scripture’s repeated condemnation of child sacrifice in the Hinnom Valley and elsewhere applies directly to abortion, leaving no room for a “free will” exemption. That is a coherent biblical-literalist position with real doctrinal lineage, not a one-off outburst. It deserves to be weighed on its own terms rather than dismissed as mere outrage.

Where the Argument Actually Turns

Strip away the inflamed rhetoric on both sides and the dispute resolves into three distinct theological questions that are too often collapsed into one. First: is abortion a sin at all? Second, if it is, can it be forgiven like any other sin? Third — the most consequential and least examined — is it affirmatively willed by God, or merely tolerated under human free will? Taylor’s quoted statements blend the second and third claims without clearly distinguishing them. Forgiveness presumes a wrong has occurred; divine approval presumes none did. Her critics seize on the strongest version of her claim — approval — while her own language leans more heavily on forgiveness and permission. That ambiguity matters, because it is the difference between a mercy theology and a sanction theology, and the available record does not show her drawing that line precisely.

Neither side’s case is resolved by appeal to a neutral authority, because none exists in this dispute the way a court record or forensic test would exist in a factual one. No single denomination speaks for Christianity on abortion, and academic research confirms as much: attitudes toward abortion across Christian traditions track more closely with beliefs about sexual ethics and the sanctity of life than with any uniform doctrinal consensus, and those beliefs vary enormously by tradition and era. Evangelical opposition to abortion, in particular, hardened over the late twentieth century rather than representing an unbroken historical position — a reminder that “what Christianity teaches” on this question has itself shifted with time and political alignment, not merely with scripture.

Why This Keeps Recurring in American Public Life

Taylor is not an isolated figure; her argument sits inside a recognizable pattern of Christian physicians and public officials invoking faith to defend abortion access, which predictably draws equally forceful theological rebuttal from conservative Christian institutions. That pattern will keep repeating because abortion politics has become a proxy for a deeper contest over religious authority itself — who gets to interpret scripture, and for whom. The absence of a full transcript, recording, or dated interview record for Taylor’s remarks leaves room for selective quotation on both sides, which is worth noting briefly but should not obscure the substantive theological stakes already visible in what has been reported and not meaningfully disputed as to its content.

For readers trying to adjudicate the underlying claim rather than the culture-war packaging around it, the honest conclusion is this: Taylor has offered a pastoral argument with internal coherence for her own patients, but it remains her individual theological position, unsupported by denominational consensus or documented exegesis in the public record. Her critics have offered a competing argument with deep scriptural precedent and institutional backing across multiple Christian organizations. Both are genuine theological claims. Neither has been, or can be, settled by evidence in the way a factual dispute can.

Sources:

lifesitenews.com, gynecology.hospital, liveaction.org, grandgoldman.com, amazon.com, coloradotimesrecorder.com